How Insurance Works Legally in South Africa: A Must Know!

How Insurance Works Legally in South Africa

Insurance legally operates in South Africa as a contract where a policyholder pays a premium to an insurer for financial protection against a specified event. The insurer is legally obligated to provide a payout if a covered, uncertain event occurs, such as damage to property or a life-related event. Key legal principles include the contract having to be based on an uncertain future event, and the insured must have an “insurable interest” in the risk being covered.

While most insurance is optional, third-party motor vehicle insurance is legally mandatory in South Africa, as detailed in the Insurance Act No 18 of 2017.

Key legal aspects of insurance in South Africa

Contractual agreement: Insurance is a legally binding contract between an individual or entity (the policyholder) and the insurance company (the insurer).

Premium and risk transfer: The policyholder pays a regular premium, and in return, the insurer assumes the financial risk of a specified event occurring.

Insurable interest: A fundamental legal principle is that the insured must have an “insurable interest” in the risk. This means the insured must be in a position to suffer a loss if the insured event occurs.

Uncertainty of event: The event insured against must be uncertain—it’s not guaranteed to happen, but it could happen in the future. The insurer must have no control over whether it occurs.

Indemnity vs. non-indemnity:

Indemnity insurance: The insurer compensates the insured for the actual, proven loss suffered (e.g., damage to a car).

Non-indemnity (or capital) insurance: The insurer agrees to pay a pre-determined sum of money upon the occurrence of the event, regardless of the actual financial loss (e.g., life insurance, where a fixed amount is paid out upon death).

Mandatory insurance: While car insurance is not universally compulsory, third-party motor vehicle insurance is a legal requirement for all vehicles on the road in South Africa.

Regulatory oversight: Insurance companies in South Africa are regulated by the Prudential Authority under the SARB, ensuring they are financially sound and follow the law.

Duty of disclosure: Policyholders have a legal duty to be truthful and disclose all material facts when applying for insurance. Failure to do so can lead to the insurer voiding the policy and not paying out a claim.

Legal Framework for Insurance in South Africa

Insurance in South Africa is mainly governed by these laws and regulators:

🏛️ Key Laws

1. Insurance Act 18 of 2017 –
   Modernized South African insurance law. It ensures insurers are financially sound, treat customers fairly, and manage risk properly.

2. Long-Term Insurance Act (No. 52 of 1998) –
   Governs life insurance, funeral policies, disability, and investment-related insurance.

3. Short-Term Insurance Act (No. 53 of 1998) –
   Covers non-life insurance such as vehicle, home, and business insurance.

4. Financial Sector Regulation Act (2017) –
   Established two key regulators:

   • FSCA – Financial Sector Conduct Authority (focuses on fair customer treatment)

   • Prudential Authority (PA) – ensures insurers remain financially stable and can pay claims.

---

🧾 2. How an Insurance Policy Works

Step 1: Proposal / Application

You apply for insurance and provide information (e.g., health, car details, or property value).
🔹 It’s important to disclose all relevant facts truthfully — non-disclosure can void your policy.

Step 2: Policy Issuance

The insurer issues a policy document — a legal contract stating:

• What risks are covered

• Premium amount

• Policy term

• Exclusions (what’s not covered)

• Claim procedures

💡 The policy is legally binding under contract law — both parties (you and the insurer) must follow the terms.

Step 3: Premium Payment

You pay a regular premium (monthly or yearly). Missing payments may cause the policy to lapse or become invalid.

Step 4: Making a Claim

If a covered event happens (e.g., car accident, death, theft), you submit a claim with proof (police report, medical certificate, receipts, etc.).
The insurer investigates and either:

• Approves and pays out the claim, or

• Rejects it (with written reasons).

---

🧑‍⚖️ 3. Your Rights and Protections

🛡️ Under South African Law, You Have the Right To:

1. Fair treatment – Insurers must act honestly and transparently.

2. Full disclosure – You must be clearly told what’s covered, excluded, and how premiums/benefits work.

3. Written policy – You must receive a copy of your policy contract.

4. Complaint resolution – If you disagree with a decision, you can complain to:

   • The insurer’s internal complaints department, or

   • The Ombudsman for Long-term Insurance (for life/funeral policies), or

   • The Ombudsman for Short-term Insurance (for car, home, business insurance).

---

⚖️ 4. The Role of the Ombudsman

The Ombudsman is an independent office that helps consumers resolve disputes free of charge.
They can:

• Investigate complaints

• Make binding decisions on insurers

• Order compensation if you were unfairly treated

👉 Website examples:

• www.osti.co.za